11 KiB
Standard Operating Procedure: Clinical Outcome Measure Administration
| Document ID | SOP-ADM-001 |
|---|---|
| Title | Clinical Outcome Measure Administration |
| Revision | 1.0 |
| Effective Date | [DATE] |
| Author | [AUTHOR] |
| Approved By | [APPROVER] |
| Department | Clinical Operations |
1. Purpose
This procedure establishes standardized requirements for administering clinical outcome measures to ensure data quality, consistency, and validity across all assessments.
2. Scope
This procedure applies to:
- Patient-Reported Outcomes (PROs)
- Clinician-Reported Outcomes (ClinROs)
- Observer-Reported Outcomes (ObsROs)
- Performance Outcomes (PerfOs)
Administered in any setting (clinic, home, remote) using paper or electronic formats.
3. Responsibilities
3.1 Study Coordinator/Clinical Research Associate
- Schedule outcome assessments
- Ensure measures are administered according to protocol
- Maintain assessment materials and equipment
- Document completion and data quality
3.2 Measure Administrator
- Complete required training for each measure
- Follow standardized administration procedures
- Respond to participant questions appropriately
- Maintain certification as required
3.3 Quality Assurance
- Monitor administration compliance
- Review assessment data for quality issues
- Provide feedback and retraining as needed
4. Definitions
| Term | Definition |
|---|---|
| PRO | Patient-Reported Outcome - Self-reported by patient without interpretation by clinician or observer |
| ClinRO | Clinician-Reported Outcome - Based on clinician observation and professional judgment |
| ObsRO | Observer-Reported Outcome - Based on caregiver/proxy observation without clinical interpretation |
| PerfO | Performance Outcome - Based on standardized task performed by patient (e.g., timed walk test) |
| Recall Period | The timeframe patients consider when responding (e.g., "in the past week") |
| Response Options | The available choices for answering items (e.g., Likert scale, visual analog scale) |
| Missing Data | Items not completed or answered "don't know/not applicable" |
5. Procedure
5.1 Pre-Administration Preparation
5.1.1. Verify administrator training and certification:
- Review measure-specific training requirements
- Confirm completion in training database
- Check certification expiration dates
- Complete refresher training if needed
5.1.2. Verify active license for proprietary measures:
- Check License Tracking Database
- Ensure protocol is covered under current license
- Review any license restrictions or requirements
5.1.3. Gather required materials:
- Current version of measure
- Administration manual/instructions
- Response forms or electronic device
- Scoring materials if immediate scoring required
- Equipment for performance measures
5.1.4. Review protocol-specific requirements:
- Timing of assessment (visit window)
- Order of measures if multiple assessments
- Special population considerations
- Conditions for assessment (fasting, medication timing, etc.)
5.1.5. Prepare assessment environment:
- Private, quiet location
- Adequate lighting
- Comfortable seating
- Free from interruptions
5.2 Patient-Reported Outcomes (PRO) Administration
5.2.1 Self-Administered PROs
5.2.1.1. Provide standardized introduction:
- Explain purpose of assessment
- Emphasize there are no right or wrong answers
- Clarify that responses are confidential
- Ask participant to complete independently
5.2.1.2. Provide written or verbal instructions:
- Read recall period carefully
- Indicate how to mark responses
- Complete all items unless instructed otherwise
- Ask questions if anything is unclear
5.2.1.3. Allow participant to complete independently:
- Remain available for questions
- Do not observe or read over shoulder
- Provide clarification only on instructions, not items
- Do not influence responses
5.2.1.4. Check for completeness:
- Review for missing items
- Ask participant to complete skipped items if appropriate
- Document reason if items remain incomplete
- Do not query or suggest changes to responses
5.2.2 Interviewer-Administered PROs
5.2.2.1. Read standardized introduction script
5.2.2.2. Read items verbatim:
- Do not paraphrase or explain items
- Repeat item if participant did not hear or understand
- If participant still unclear, document as "unable to understand"
5.2.2.3. Read response options clearly:
- Present all available response options
- May use response cards for visual reference
- Allow participant to answer in their own words, then map to options
5.2.2.4. Record responses accurately:
- Mark participant's initial response
- Do not query or seek clarification of responses
- If participant changes answer, record final response
5.2.2.5. Handle participant questions:
- Questions about instructions: answer clearly
- Questions about item meaning: repeat item only
- Questions about which response to choose: "whatever is most accurate for you"
5.3 Clinician-Reported Outcomes (ClinRO) Administration
5.3.1. Review available clinical information:
- Recent medical records
- Laboratory/diagnostic results
- Previous ClinRO scores for comparison
5.3.2. Conduct clinical evaluation:
- Patient interview if required
- Physical examination if required
- Review of symptoms and functional status
5.3.3. Apply clinical judgment:
- Consider all available information
- Rate according to measure definitions
- Use anchors and examples provided in measure
- Document supporting observations
5.3.4. Complete independently:
- Do not confer with other raters before rating
- For training/reliability, may compare after independent rating
- Document any disagreements and resolution process
5.4 Observer-Reported Outcomes (ObsRO) Administration
5.4.1. Verify observer qualifications:
- Appropriate relationship to patient (caregiver, parent, etc.)
- Adequate opportunity to observe relevant behaviors
- Adequate cognitive ability to complete assessment
5.4.2. Provide observer instructions:
- Base responses on direct observation
- Consider specified recall period
- Answer based on what you have observed, not what you think
5.4.3. Follow PRO administration procedures (Section 5.2)
5.4.4. Consider proxy response implications:
- Patient-proxy agreement may vary by domain
- Document observer relationship and contact frequency
- Note if patient unable to self-report and reason
5.5 Performance Outcomes (PerfO) Administration
5.5.1. Ensure standardized conditions:
- Consistent time of day if performance varies
- Consider effects of medications or meals
- Appropriate rest before assessment
- Safe environment and equipment
5.5.2. Demonstrate task if required:
- Follow standardized demonstration script
- Ensure participant understands task
- Allow practice trial if permitted
5.5.3. Administer performance test:
- Use standardized instructions verbatim
- Follow specified timing procedures
- Apply stopping rules if specified
- Ensure safety throughout
5.5.4. Record performance objectively:
- Time, distance, or other metrics
- Note any deviations from standard administration
- Document reasons for incomplete assessments
5.5.5. Provide feedback appropriately:
- Follow measure guidelines on feedback
- Generally, do not provide performance results immediately
- Thank participant for effort
5.6 Electronic Administration (eCOA)
5.6.1. Verify electronic system:
- System is functioning properly
- Correct measure and version loaded
- Appropriate participant ID entered
- Data connection available if required
5.6.2. Provide device orientation:
- How to read and respond to items
- How to navigate forward/backward if permitted
- How to submit/save responses
- Technical support contact information
5.6.3. Monitor for technical issues:
- Device malfunction
- Software errors
- Loss of data connection
- Document issues and resolution
5.6.4. Have paper backup available:
- Use only if electronic system failure
- Document reason for paper administration
- Follow procedures for paper-to-electronic data entry
5.7 Timing and Scheduling
5.7.1. Adhere to protocol visit windows:
- Schedule within specified timeframe
- Document actual assessment date and time
- If outside window, document reason
5.7.2. Consider order effects:
- Follow protocol-specified order if required
- For fatigue-sensitive measures, administer early
- Allow breaks between measures if needed
5.7.3. Avoid contamination:
- PROs before clinical assessments when possible
- Blind PRO responses from clinicians when appropriate
- ClinRO raters blind to other outcomes when required
5.8 Missing Data Management
5.8.1. Minimize missing data:
- Review for completeness during visit
- Ask participant to complete missed items when appropriate
- Document reason if items not completed
5.8.2. Acceptable reasons for missing items:
- Item not applicable to participant
- Participant refused to answer
- Participant unable to understand item
- Technical issue prevented response capture
5.8.3. Unacceptable approaches:
- Administrator answering on behalf of participant
- Coercing responses
- Querying responses to reduce variability
- Imputing responses during administration
5.9 Documentation
5.9.1. Complete required documentation:
- Assessment completion log
- Deviations from standard administration
- Missing data with reasons
- Technical issues or protocol deviations
- Administrator name and date
5.9.2. Ensure data quality:
- Verify all required items completed
- Check for logical inconsistencies
- Resolve data queries promptly
- Maintain source documentation
6. Related Documents
- WI-XXX: Measure-specific work instructions
- FRM-ADM-001: Assessment Completion Log
- FRM-TRN-001: Administrator Training Record
- SOP-DM-001: Data Management
- SOP-LIC-001: License Management
7. References
- FDA (2009). Guidance for Industry: Patient-Reported Outcome Measures
- Acquadro C, et al. (2008). Incorporating the patient's perspective into drug development and communication: an ad hoc task force report of the Patient-Reported Outcomes (PRO) Harmonization Group meeting at the Food and Drug Administration
- EMA (2005). Reflection Paper on the Regulatory Guidance for the Use of Health-Related Quality of Life (HRQL) Measures in the Evaluation of Medicinal Products
Revision History
| Rev | Date | Description | Author |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.0 | [DATE] | Initial release | [AUTHOR] |